The Nantucket Jacket, designed by Norah Gaughan, is a gorgeous garment! It looks good on everyone that I have seen wear it. It has cables and seed stitch and twisted stitches. Just enough variation in the pattern to make it a fun and interesting knit without being so overwhelming that you need to watch a chart.
That being said, I have found one problem that I would like to address for any hapless soul that is going to put the work into making this gorgeous piece of knitwear. The gauge isn’t right! No, it isn’t just a little off, it is waaaaaay off. Let me explain.

I am not a small person. I did my gauge swatch, I always do my gauge swatch. Don’t hate me because I can knit, hate me because I swatch. Anyway, I got the perfect 18 sts and 24 rows for 4 inches. Then I did the second recommended swatch and got the perfect 24 sts and 24 rows to 4 inches again. Did I say perfect? It was spot on perfect!
With full confidence that this would be a garment that I could wear and feel proud of, I cast on for the size that the schematic showed would fit me the best. I began to knit. My sweater to wear on the move “Back East” was progressing quickly. It was proving to be a fun knit. The yarn was working up wonderfully! Then, as I was working on about the 5th decrease for the skirt, a light went on in my head. Then a voice rang out in the zen-like silence that comes over me when I am working on a satisfying, gratifying project.
“Hey”
“What!”
“Hey You!”
“What!”
“Did you realize that you are using 32″ circulars?“
“Well, yes.”
“Do you see a problem here?“
“What?”
“Don’t start that again. Just go get a tape measure and measure that puppy!“
I got up, not wanting to anger the voice in my head, and got my trusty little measure. I laid the knitted piece out and, without measuring, saw a leetle bit of a big problem.
I was using 32″ circulars. Oh, my inner zen voice already pointed that out, right?
Right. The skirt, after 5 decreases, was wider than my needles were long. I measured.
“Crrrrrrrrrrrap!” said very loudly with a very satisfying rolling of the r. Not very zen-like, I admit.
It measured in at a full 48 inches! That wouldn’t have been so bad if I was knitting the entire body of the sweater in one piece. But, this was the back I was working on here!
I muttered a few very vile words and did some measuring and calculating.
Damn!
How could this be?
My gauge swatches were both right!
Spot on!
What happened?
In order to get the size I needed, I would have to go down to the small! I am not a small person! I didn’t want to go down in needle size because of the need for the length provided by the row count. And, because my gauge was spot on, what needle size would I go down to anyway? Is there an errata on this that I am not aware of?
Armed with the knowledge of the size I would have to make, I dove into the frog pond, muttering and grumbling the entire time.
I was amazed when, after casting on for the smaller size, how quickly the skirt reformed.
“Fewer stitches, Bozo“
“Oh - STFU!“